All posts
November 10, 20269 min readtristramt

Worst Overall to First Overall (Part 3)

Ranking all the quarterbacks drafted first overall since 2000

5. Matthew Stafford (Detroit Lions, 2009)

Stats

Matthew Stafford stats

Postseason & Accolades

  • 0-3 playoff record with the Lions
  • 7-2 playoff record with the Rams
  • Super Bowl champion and Super Bowl MVP (2021 season – Rams)
  • NFL MVP (2025 – Rams)
  • Pro Bowl (2014 – Lions; 2023, 2025 – Rams)

Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

2009 QB class

Without question. The only other quarterback who had any success in this class was Mark Sanchez, but like all 15 quarterbacks drafted by the Jets since 2000, his tenure with them was doomed to failure (though I guess the story hasn't been completely written on Geno Smith).

Verdict

Matthew Stafford is the first quarterback on this list with a Super Bowl ring, and yet he still lands at only fifth place. That's because even though he played twelve years for the team that drafted him, all he had to show for it was three playoff appearances, each ending in a first-round exit. It wasn't until he was traded to the Rams that his star really began to rise. Sure, his connection with Calvin Johnson was a thing of beauty, but ultimately his time in Detroit wasn't as successful as the Lions hoped when they drafted him.

His talent has always been undeniable, so perhaps the blame lies squarely on the Lions' shoulders. After all, he's the same player who led Sean McVay's Rams to a Super Bowl win and was voted MVP last year, if a little older and wiser. He and the next quarterback on this list are good reminders that no matter how talented a quarterback is, the players and coaching staff around him are just as important, if not more.


4. Jared Goff (Los Angeles Rams, 2016)

Stats

Jared Goff stats

Postseason & Accolades

  • 3-3 playoff record with the Rams
  • 2-2 playoff record with the Lions
  • Super Bowl appearance (2018 season – Rams, loss)
  • Pro Bowl (2017, 2018 – Rams; 2022, 2024, 2025 – Lions)

Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

2016 QB class

This is an interesting conversation. Jared Goff has thrown for the most yards and touchdowns, and the fewest interceptions, of any quarterback in this class. Dak Prescott, the Cowboys' fourth-round pick, is second in each category. But Dak has also played the second-most games, while Goff has played the most. So if you do the math, Goff has thrown for 263.75 yards per game to Dak's 258.18, while Dak edges him in touchdowns per game, 1.75 to 1.72.

I think Dak is generally considered the better quarterback, but I'm not convinced that's fair. Goff certainly has his flaws, and they were exploited in humiliating fashion on the biggest stage there is: the Super Bowl. But at least he made the Super Bowl, something Dak Prescott has yet to do. Oh, and Carson Wentz was in this class too.

Verdict

Forever tied to Stafford by the trade that changed the trajectory of both teams, Goff gets the nod on my list because he was more successful with the team that drafted him, even if he hasn't been as successful with the team that traded for him. Still, he's been good for the Lions, and if they can ever get through a season without losing every single defensive starter to injury, he may get another shot at the Super Bowl.


3. Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals, 2020)

Stats

Joe Burrow stats

Postseason & Accolades

  • 5-2 playoff record with the Bengals
  • Super Bowl appearance (2021 season – Bengals, loss)
  • Pro Bowl (2022, 2024, 2025)
  • NFL Comeback Player of the Year (2021, 2024)

Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

2020 QB class

No. That honor belongs to Tua Tagovailoa.

…

Juuuust kidding. But the first five quarterbacks taken in this class have all shown promise at some point over the last six seasons. Yes, even Tua. He did lead the NFL in passing yards in 2023, after all. Sure, you can give all the credit for that to Mike McDaniel, and most people do, but I stand by the fact that Tua showed promise… until he didn't.

Speaking of Mike McDaniel and showing promise until not: until this season, Justin Herbert was considered by many to be Burrow's biggest rival for this honor. But after throwing an interception in each of his first eight games (and losing all of them), that consideration has waned. Can you blame McDaniel for Herbert's struggles and credit him for Tua's success? Some people sure do.

Then there's Jordan Love, the analytics nerds' new toy now that Herbert's star has fallen. As of this writing (after Week 9 of 2026), he's leading the league in passing yards after smoking the Patriots. He's been good for the Packers, and there's a real chance he becomes the second QB from this class to win a Super Bowl for the team that drafted him. The first was Jalen Hurts, who has already won one with the Eagles. He's dealing with health issues now, and even before that his public perception had wavered, but he's still inarguably the most successful QB from this class so far. As far as pure skill goes, though, Burrow still looks like number one.

Verdict

Burrow looked the part of the #1 pick right off the bat. Unfortunately, those two Comeback Player of the Year awards tell his story better than that single Super Bowl appearance. Injuries and a terrible defense have kept the Bengals out of the playoffs since 2022. Still, Burrow's talent is undeniable, and we're all just waiting for the day the stars align and he leads the Bengals back to the Super Bowl. Hopefully that happens soon, because there are already rumors he's considering asking for a trade out of Cincinnati, and at this point not many people would blame him. Maybe this is the year: the Bengals are currently 6-2, and Burrow, Chase and Higgins are playing lights-out football. Either way, Burrow still looks like a great pick.


2. Cam Newton (Carolina Panthers, 2011)

Stats

Cam Newton stats

Postseason & Accolades

  • 3-4 playoff record with the Panthers
  • Super Bowl appearance (2015 season – Panthers, loss)
  • NFL MVP (2015)
  • AP Offensive Player of the Year (2015)
  • AP Offensive Rookie of the Year (2011)
  • First-Team All-Pro (2015)
  • Pro Bowl (2011, 2013, 2015)

Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

2011 QB class

I think the answer is probably yes. Andy Dalton leads him in pretty much every passing statistic, but Cam's rushing ability made him a much more potent weapon. For context, Cam ran for 5,064 yards and 60 touchdowns in his first eight seasons with Carolina. Josh Allen, currently in his eighth season with Buffalo, has rushed for 4,991 yards and 88 touchdowns. Newton was an evolution of the dual-threat quarterback at the time. There are some other interesting names in the 2011 class, like Tyrod Taylor, Colin Kaepernick and Christian Ponder, but Newton remains the top of the class.

Verdict

I gave Newton the #2 spot over Burrow mainly because Burrow has yet to have a truly elite MVP season like Newton's in 2015. The key word there is yet. Newton's career had a disappointing ending, but we can't let that overshadow just how good he was in his first few years in the NFL. If I do this exercise again in five years or so, maybe Burrow will have passed him. Heck, any of the players on this list who are still in the NFL could, even Cam Ward… but for now, I think Cam Newton was the second most valuable first overall pick quarterback for the team that drafted him.


The team that drafted him? Or the team that acquired him during the draft? Those mean different things, but for this exercise the distinction doesn't matter. I don't care which team submitted his name on draft night. I care which team signed him out of college, and which team he played his entire rookie season for… and then some.

Why make the distinction, you may ask? Because if I don't, then technically no quarterback picked first overall since 2000 (or more accurately, since 1998) has won a Super Bowl for the team that drafted him. In fact, only three quarterbacks in NFL history have won Super Bowl rings with the team that drafted them #1 overall: Terry Bradshaw (Steelers, 1970), Troy Aikman (Cowboys, 1989) and Peyton Manning (Colts, 1998).

But two other quarterbacks were drafted first overall and traded during or shortly after the draft, and they qualify too. The first was John Elway, drafted in 1983 by the Baltimore Colts and immediately traded to the Denver Broncos. The second was…


1. Eli Manning (New York Giants, 2004)

Stats

Eli Manning stats

Postseason & Accolades

  • 8-4 playoff record with the Giants
  • 2x Super Bowl champion (2007 and 2011 seasons)
  • 2x Super Bowl MVP (2007 and 2011 seasons)
  • Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year (2016)
  • Pro Bowl (2008, 2011, 2012, 2015)
  • Hall of Fame finalist (2025, 2026 – not yet elected)

Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

2004 QB class

The three big names in this class were Manning, Philip Rivers and Ben Roethlisberger. As mentioned above, Manning was originally drafted by the Chargers, but he was immediately traded to the Giants for 4th overall pick Philip Rivers and a bunch of draft picks. Rivers went on to play 18 seasons over a 22-year span: 16 with the Chargers and two with the Colts (yes, I know, it's a long story). Then there was Roethlisberger, who played 18 seasons with the Pittsburgh Steelers and also won two Super Bowls.

Which of them was the best is a tough call, and probably too subjective a call to make. Rivers threw the most touchdowns of the three and the second-most yards, while Roethlisberger had the most yards and the second-most touchdowns. Eli was third in both. But Eli and Roethlisberger each won two Super Bowls, while Rivers never made it past the AFC Championship Game (which he reached only once). So Roethlisberger is probably the best, but I can understand anyone who'd want to argue otherwise.

Verdict

So yeah, by virtue of leading the Giants to two Super Bowl wins, Eli Manning is the most valuable quarterback picked first overall in the twenty-first century. His legacy will always be a bit murky given his overall performance, as evidenced by the fact that he's been a Hall of Fame finalist twice without being selected. Most Giants fans will confess that rooting for him was frustrating at times, but that confession will always be laced with affection. They got to enjoy two Super Bowl wins thanks to him, while many of us have never experienced even one, and maybe never will.


The Takeaway

This brings me to my biggest takeaway from this exercise: picking a quarterback number one overall is not the fast track to success we all still treat it as. I was surprised by how little all of these quarterbacks delivered for the teams that drafted them. Sure, most of the players on this list are considered good, but it's telling that there are only three Super Bowl rings among all 19 of them, and not a single Hall of Famer. Of course, the story isn't completely written for about half of these guys, so maybe that narrative will change in the near future.

Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.

Buy me a coffee
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.