Worst Overall to First Overall (Part 2)
Ranking all the quarterbacks drafted first overall since 2000
12. Baker Mayfield (Cleveland Browns, 2018)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1-1 playoff record with Cleveland
- 1-2 playoff record with Tampa Bay
- Pro Bowl (2023, 2024 – both with Tampa Bay)
- Highest career playoff passer rating in NFL history (105.9, min. 150 attempts)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

No. One other quarterback in this class has a Super Bowl ring, and two others are named Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson. To be fair, Sam Darnold's ring didn't come with the team that drafted him, but it's safe to say that if the 2018 draft had a do-over, there's no world in which Baker Mayfield goes first.
Verdict
Baker's tenure with the Browns is pretty notorious: he helped end their playoff drought, only to be unceremoniously dumped for Deshaun Watson, a move that set the franchise back for years (yes, I know Watson is currently playing well, but it was still a terrible move). After bouncing around a bit, Baker has found success in Tampa Bay. Not a ton of success, mind you, but he's made a name for himself as a reliable starter.
11. Alex Smith (San Francisco 49ers, 2005)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1-1 playoff record with the 49ers
- 1-4 playoff record with the Chiefs
- Pro Bowl (2013, 2016, 2017 – all with the Chiefs)
- NFL passer rating leader (2017 – Chiefs)
- NFL Comeback Player of the Year (2020 – Washington)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

No. However you feel about the guy, Aaron Rodgers is undeniably a better quarterback than Alex Smith. And shout-out to my guy Ryan Fitzpatrick. I'm not saying he was better than Alex Smith, but I'd be remiss not to mention him here. He just seems like a cool guy.
Verdict
When I began crafting this list, Alex Smith was much higher, but as I dug into the numbers I kept having to drop him. In my mind, he's a steady veteran who rarely loses you games, even if he doesn't necessarily win them either. But this exercise is about his value to the team that drafted him first overall, and in that context the 49ers didn't really get their money's worth. His record as a starter over seven seasons in San Francisco was 38-36-1. Not terrible, but not great either, which… kind of describes his entire career. He certainly had a stronger run in Kansas City before being replaced by a young upstart named Patrick Mahomes. Perhaps you've heard of him?
10. Carson Palmer (Cincinnati Bengals, 2003)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 0-2 playoff record with Cincinnati
- 1-1 playoff record with Arizona
- Pro Bowl (2005, 2006 – Bengals; 2015 – Cardinals)
- NFL passing touchdowns leader (32 TDs, 2005 – Bengals)
- NFL completion percentage leader (67.8%, 2005 – Bengals)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

I think it's safe to say he was, if only because of his resurgence in Arizona. His classmates include some names better known for what they did after their playing days, like coaches Ken Dorsey, Kliff Kingsbury and Byron Leftwich, and hot-take artist Chris Simms.
Verdict
Like Alex Smith, Palmer is lower on this list than I expected at first glance because of his tenure with the team that drafted him. His record with the Bengals (46-51) is worse than Smith's with the 49ers, but I'm giving Palmer the higher spot because he led the Bengals to their first winning season and playoff appearance in 15 years, which has to count for something. Unfortunately, he tore his ACL and MCL on his very first pass attempt of that playoff game, a bit of an omen for the rest of his time in Cincinnati. He eventually forced his way out, but the Bengals still got a 1st- and a 2nd-round pick for him, so… I guess they got their money's worth after all?
9. Trevor Lawrence (Jacksonville Jaguars, 2021)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1-2 playoff record
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Yes. He's the only quarterback from that class who is still a starter.
Verdict
I originally had Trevor Lawrence ahead of Caleb Williams, but I'm putting him just behind Williams on this list (spoiler). Here's my reasoning: their stories mirror each other. Both struggled with subpar coaching and team management until a new coach came in and built a scheme around their strengths (Liam Coen for Lawrence, Ben Johnson for Williams). But Lawrence didn't become the elite player his draft position promised until year five, after his contract had been extended, while Williams got there in year two, still on his rookie deal. That return on investment is the tiebreaker.
I'm not saying Caleb is better than Lawrence. In fact, Lawrence has been electric to watch through most of 2025 and so far in 2026… but the time it took to get him there is a factor. Sure, it might not have been his fault (who can forget the Urban Meyer fiasco), but almost every player on this list was drafted by a bad team. That's how they got the number one pick in the first place. Yes, I recognize that's not exactly true for the Bears and Caleb, but I stand by my decision.
8. Caleb Williams (Chicago Bears, 2024)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1-1 playoff record (2025 season)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

The real answer is that it's too early to tell, but it's still an interesting conversation. This draft saw six quarterbacks taken in the first round, and all six are currently starting.
- J.J. McCarthy is disqualified because he's not starting for the team that drafted him; his tenure with the Vikings was an unmitigated disaster.
- Bo Nix, the 12th pick, was probably Super Bowl bound last year if not for a brutal ankle injury at the very end of a playoff game.
- Michael Penix Jr., the 8th pick, has flashed when he's been on the field. Unfortunately, he hasn't been on the field much.
- Drake Maye, the 3rd pick, had a great season last year that ended in a Super Bowl loss, and despite a rocky start he looks great again this season.
- Jayden Daniels, the 2nd pick, had an incredible rookie year, but injuries to him and key teammates have held his team back since.
And then there's Caleb, whose rookie struggles were largely blamed on the coaching staff. Since Ben Johnson took over, he has improved greatly. So again, it's too early to say whether Caleb Williams will be the best QB in his class, but it's becoming pretty clear he is no bust.
Verdict
Not much to add beyond what I said above. After a rocky rookie season, Caleb has looked the part of a number one overall pick. Of course, this being the NFL, things could change, but at this point I don't think anyone would be surprised if he becomes the first QB in this class to win a Super Bowl. I'd bet at least one of these guys will have a ring before all is said and done… why not him?
7. Michael Vick (Atlanta Falcons, 2001)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 2-2 playoff record with Atlanta (NFC Championship appearance)
- 0-1 playoff record with Philadelphia
- 3 Pro Bowls with Atlanta (2002, 2004, 2005)
- 1 Pro Bowl with Philadelphia (2010)
- NFL Comeback Player of the Year (2010)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Framed as which team got the better deal, Atlanta drafting Vick or the Chargers drafting Drew Brees, it's actually a tough call. Neither team got what it paid for, despite both players being incredible. Looking at their entire careers, though, the nod has to go to Brees, who broke records and won a Super Bowl in New Orleans.
Verdict
For anyone who doesn't know the story: in 2007, after six seasons with the Falcons, Michael Vick pleaded guilty to federal dogfighting conspiracy charges and was sentenced to 23 months in prison. He eventually returned to the NFL with the Eagles, but in the context of being a good first overall pick for the Falcons, he was a disappointment, no matter how talented he was.
6. Andrew Luck (Indianapolis Colts, 2012)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 4-4 playoff record with the Colts
- Pro Bowl (2012, 2013, 2014, 2018)
- AP NFL Comeback Player of the Year (2018)
- NFL passing touchdowns leader (40 TDs, 2014)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Man, I still want to say yes. Sure, Robert Griffin III won Offensive Rookie of the Year, Russell Wilson was the most successful, and Kirk Cousins is still playing at a relatively high level to this day. Heck, even Ryan Tannehill had a longer career and a couple of playoff wins… but man, Andrew Luck was so good. If we could redo the 2012 draft, I think I'd still take Luck first and then spend every remaining pick on offensive linemen. The lack of protection he had to endure was a travesty, and he still played at a high level. His is a cautionary tale that echoes David Carr's.
Verdict
Remember "Suck for Luck"? I sure do. The Colts were so ready to move on from Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning (who would be the indisputable number one on this list if it went back to 1998) that they tanked the 2011 season to draft Andrew Luck first overall in 2012. Well, they got the Luck but forgot to get rid of the suck. Poor Andrew Luck had to carry the team on his back between injury rehabs until he'd had enough of it all and retired. It was a move that stunned the entire NFL, and one the organization still hasn't recovered from. For that reason, maybe he should be lower on this list, but man, he was so good for them when he was upright.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee