Worst Overall to First Overall (Part 1)
Ranking all the quarterbacks drafted first overall since 2000
Ranking Every No. 1 Overall Pick Quarterback Since 2000
Honorable Mentions
Mitchell Trubisky: #2 over Mahomes #10 (2017)
Mitchell Trubisky was not taken first overall, so he doesn't qualify for this list. But he was taken second, and most notably, the Bears traded up from the #3 spot to the #2 spot to get him while a certain someone named Patrick Mahomes remained on the board. Perhaps you've heard of him. I have no intention of rubbing salt in the Bears' wound (okay, maybe a little), and it seems like the Bears finally got a good one seven years later… but this is a good illustration of how little we all know about these guys come draft day.
Fernando Mendoza (2026)
Mendoza was the first pick of the 2026 draft. At the time of writing, only three games have been played in the 2026 season, and Mendoza has not played a single snap. In fact, none of the quarterbacks drafted this year have played yet, which is actually unusual. It would be unfair to include him anywhere on this list.

That means a total of 19 quarterbacks have been selected with the number one overall pick in the NFL Draft since 2000. I'm going to rank them from 19 (the biggest bust) to 1 (the greatest success).
Context: These QBs are rated on how valuable they were to the team that drafted them. So the question isn't who is the best quarterback? It's which teams got their money's worth?
19. JaMarcus Russell (Oakland Raiders, 2007)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
None.
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

No, obviously not, but no one else in that class had long, sterling careers either. Drew Stanton and Trent Edwards tied for the most games played (37), Trent Edwards threw for the most yards (6,033), and Kevin Kolb threw for the most touchdowns (28). In fact, 2007 could be in the running for the worst QB class ever.
Verdict
There's nowhere to begin this list other than right here, with the man whose name has become synonymous with bust. Back when rookies could demand contracts instead of earning a set salary based on where they were drafted, Russell nabbed himself a $30 million guaranteed contract from the Raiders, a team he would start only 31 games for over three seasons before leaving the NFL completely. The stories about this fiasco are endless (like when coaches gave him a DVD to study the playbook and it came back blank), and they serve to this day as a warning to measure character and motivation in addition to physical attributes and skill. His fall from grace is the stuff of legend, and his deal was probably one of the biggest reasons the structure of rookie contracts changed so drastically.
18. David Carr (Houston Texans, 2002)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
None.
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Josh McCown is the only QB from this class to play in more NFL games than Carr (99 to 94). He also threw for more yards (17,727 to 14,458) and more touchdowns (98 to 89), so I guess the answer is no, Carr was not the best QB in his own class.
Verdict
If JaMarcus Russell is the ultimate cautionary tale about vetting your prospective quarterback, David Carr is the ultimate cautionary tale about building a decent team around him so he has a chance to succeed. Granted, most teams have the number one overall pick because they're bad, but there's a difference between "rebuilding" bad and "letting your rookie quarterback get sacked 76 times" bad. Unlike Russell, Carr had a decent-length career: 10 years. But in those 10 years he was sacked 267 times, 249 of them during his six years in Houston. That's what he became known for, and by the time he left Houston he didn't seem to have much left in the tank, never playing more than six games in a season for any other team. When your rookie quarterback sets the record for sacks taken, that's a team failure. Carr remains a sad "what if?" story.
17. Cam Ward (Tennessee Titans, 2025)
Summary
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
None yet.
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

At this point, it doesn't look like it. Jaxson Dart has flashed the brightest when he's been on the field, but Tyler Shough has been the most consistent. Neither of the two Browns draftees from this class has impressed much, and neither did 7th-round pick Quinn Ewers when he got his shot in Miami.
Verdict
Cam Ward has only played in 26 NFL games, so it's unfair to rank him here. But 25 of those 26 games haven't exactly inspired a lot of hope. Funnily enough, I'm writing this after week 8 of the 2026 season in which he played pretty well against the Bengals. The Titans still lost the game, but it was good to see him find some success. So the jury is still out, but so far he hasn't done much this season to suggest he needs to move up this list.
16. Bryce Young (Carolina Panthers, 2023)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1 playoff appearance (lost in the Wild Card round 2025)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

If you'd asked anyone this two years ago, the answer would have been a resounding "no," since C.J. Stroud had an undeniably better rookie season. But since then, Stroud's star has fallen while Young's has risen. You could argue it's simply a matter of the Panthers doing a better job of building around their young QB than the Texans, but Young's growth and increased confidence are obvious.
Outside of Stroud, he doesn't have much competition. Anthony Richardson had his shot and was cast aside in favor of Daniel Jones. Will Levis got thrown into the sea in Tennessee to see if he could swim and sank like a stone. Aidan O'Connell had a shot, but the Raiders have moved on. Stetson Bennett could get a shot in L.A. soon, considering Stafford's age. Tanner McKee is currently starting for the Eagles, but his performance has yet to be encouraging.
Verdict
Bryce Young is a good reminder for teams to be patient with their young (no pun intended) QBs. Technically, the Panthers weren't patient with him and gave up early; only an Andy Dalton car crash gave him the second chance he needed to prove himself. But he's playing well this season, and he may soon climb this list.
15. Sam Bradford (St. Louis Rams, 2010)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year (2010)
- Rookie record for most completions (354)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Probably yes. Tim Tebow and Colt McCoy may be names with louder echoes, but in terms of stats and impact on the team that drafted him, Bradford was the best pick, even though his career was hindered by injuries.
Verdict
Sam Bradford's biggest legacy is being the catalyst for changing the rookie contract system. He signed a six-year, $78 million contract with the St. Louis Rams that included $50 million guaranteed… all before playing a single snap in the NFL. In 2011, the new CBA introduced a rookie wage scale. For comparison, the 2011 number one pick, Cam Newton (who can be found much further down this list), signed a four-year, $22 million contract.
14. Jameis Winston (Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 2015)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- Pro Bowl (2015)
- Led the league in passing yards (5,109 in 2019)
Funnily enough, his only playoff appearance came in 2021 with the Saints against the Buccaneers, when he came in for a single trick play and threw a 56-yard touchdown. The Saints lost to the Bucs, so you could argue his one playoff appearance helped the team that drafted him.
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

Technically his story is still being written, as is #2 pick Marcus Mariota's. Both started in Week 3 this season, subbing in for injured starters. That said, the general consensus is that Winston has had the better career. The only other 2015 QB who could be in the conversation is Trevor Siemian, who had some success in Denver, but… no, Winston is the winner.
Verdict
Like I said, he's still playing, and he was doing well for the Giants before losing his job to J.J. McCarthy. He became a bit of a punchline with his 30-touchdown, 30-interception season. He definitely has a talented arm, but it doesn't make up for his constant mistakes.
13. Kyler Murray (Arizona Cardinals, 2019)
Stats

Postseason & Accolades
- 1 playoff appearance in 2021 (lost in the Wild Card round)
- NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year (2019)
- Pro Bowl (2020, 2021)
Was he even the best quarterback in his class?

If you'd asked me exactly a year ago, when the Daniel Jones–led Colts were a historically dominant offense and the Cardinals were relying on Jacoby Brissette after Murray got hurt five mediocre weeks in, the answer might have been Jones. But we're talking about impact on the team that drafted them, and I think Murray was better for the Cardinals than Jones was for the Giants, despite Arizona's (very public) frustration. Gardner Minshew has had some highs, but not really for the Jaguars; same with Drew Lock and the Broncos. And RIP Dwayne Haskins, who definitely had potential before his tragic death.
Verdict
Like Winston before him, Kyler Murray has become his own punchline, with his well-documented love of video games and a tendency to fade as the season goes on. The Cardinals are currently paying him to not be on their team as he plays for Minnesota. Still, there are times when he looks like the number one pick the Cardinals were hoping for, but those times are becoming less and less frequent.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee