Week 9 Fantasy Underachievers
A look at the players who missed their projections in week 9
)

The Injury Effect
Typically, a number of the people on the underperforming list will be because of injury. I’m not going to give these players the same attention I give the others because their inclusion on this list doesn’t tell us much other than they have bad luck.
- Josh Jacobs (−13.8) [Fractured finger/hand on a stiff arm in the 1st quarter, did not return — Green Bay hopes he can play with a splint]
- Malik Willis (−11.8) [Groin issue that surfaced during the game. He has been placed on IR]
The Ricochet
These are some players who, while they weren’t injured themselves, saw a dip in numbers because someone else on their team (likely their quarterback) got injured.
Jaxon Smith-Njigba scoring 12.1 vs 23.3 projected (−11.2) - Drew Lock was under center for Seattle and JSN still caught 7 of 10 targets… for 51 yards and no touchdowns. It was his lowest score of the season and it's not his fault. Lock is now dealing with an elbow/oblique issue and Seattle's starting left tackle and left guard are out too. I said in a recent post that JSN is QB and game-script proof… that remains true: few other receivers would even have scored 12 points dealing with what he’s dealing with, but he’s not invulnerable.
‘Tis But A Flesh Wound
Jahmyr Gibbs scoring 13.4 vs 26.7 projected (−13.3) - 13.4 points is his lowest of the season, but it's still 13.4 points, so… calm down. Miami stuffed him six times on 20 carries and he didn't catch a pass for the first time since week 4 of 2024. One bad matchup. He's still Jahmyr Gibbs.
Adonai Mitchell scoring 0.0 vs 9.6 projected (−9.6) - Last week Mitchell was a Debutant with 7 catches for 142 yards against the Raiders. This week? Seven targets, zero catches, zero yards in Kansas City. That's an impressively bad stat line. But seven targets means the Jets are still looking for him, and he's seen 58 targets in eight games with New York. The volume is there. A goose egg on seven looks is more of a fluke than a trend.
That Guy Said He Wasn’t Bitten By A Zombie, But He Sure Is Sweaty
Jared Goff scoring 5.3 vs 21.5 projected (−16.2) - 170 yards on a season-low 25 pass attempts in a 19-9 win at Miami. That's two straight games under 10 points for Goff, and he's averaged about 10 points per game since week 5. Shedeur Sanders outscored him by 17.4 points this week. Detroit has four indoor games coming up and Goff is much better at home, so hold on… but he's sweating.
D'Andre Swift scoring 3.1 vs 17.6 projected (−14.5) - 12 carries for 31 yards and zero targets against Tampa Bay. Swift has averaged 2.9 yards per carry over his last four games, and he was only getting the volume because Kyle Monangai is out. When Monangai is back after the bye, Swift's role gets smaller. He was on the overperformers list last week, but the trend is going the wrong way.
Jonathan Taylor scoring 9.4 vs 18.2 projected (−8.8) - Back-to-back weeks on this list and back-to-back weeks under 10 points. Taylor had 64 total yards on 18 touches (3.5 yards per carry) against Dallas, his carry share is down to 58% over the last three weeks, and Seth McGowan took his goal-line work when Taylor's shoe came off. His name came up in rumors before the trade deadline. [Update with whether he was traded before you post.]
Old Yeller This Guy (Metaphorically, of course)
Carson Wentz scoring −2.8 vs 11.8 projected (−14.6) - With Kyler Murray out with a hamstring strain, Wentz got the Monday night start against Buffalo and threw for 81 yards and two interceptions on 25 attempts. Negative points from your quarterback, again. Wentz was a fun story in week 1, but if you picked him up as a Kyler fill-in, it's time to let him go and find someone else. The Vikings traded for Cousins so Wentz's time is done in Minnesota.
Wait, Who Projected That?
In the spirit of honesty: these guys are here because of my projections, not because of anything they did. Listen, my new model is a work in progress
Justin Fields scoring −2.1 vs 11.8 projected (−13.9), Mac Jones scoring −0.3 vs 9.5 projected (−9.8) and Davis Mills scoring 0.1 vs 9.1 projected (−9.0) - Between them: two pass attempts and 7 passing yards. Fields and Jones didn't throw a single pass, and Mills only got in for garbage time in Houston's 44-22 blowout. None of them were starting, so none of them should have been projected for 9-12 points. That's on me, not them. Consider this my public apology to all three.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee