Week 9 Fantasy Overachievers
A look at the players who exceeded their projections in week 9
)

The Injury Effect
These players outperformed their weekly projections because of an injury to someone else on their team, the opposing defense, or some other one time quirk.
Shedeur Sanders scoring 22.7 vs 5.5 projected (+17.1) - Another example of a projection that missed, and this time I can't blame FantasyPros: we knew Watson was sitting this game out with a concussion, and my model still only gave Sanders 5.5 points (work in progress, remember?). Sanders got his first start of the season and threw for 297 yards and two touchdowns with no interceptions, including a 64-yard bomb to KC Concepcion. He nearly won it in overtime before the Saints stopped the 2-point try. He took five sacks and the turnover risk is real, but he played better than most thought he would, even ignoring the bad projection. I guess we’ll see if he remains the starter for Cleveland once Watson clears protocol.
The Flash in the Pan
[Note: I have a vivid memory from high school of my PE teacher calling the Foo Fighters a flash in the pan. He was wrong, and I freely admit that I may be wrong here, but these are players that seem unlikely to continue to exceed expectations.]
Kayshon Boutte scoring 28.5 vs 5.4 projected (+23.1) & Tank Dell scoring 20.5 vs 3.5 projected (+17.0) & C.J. Stroud scoring 35.4 vs 16.9 projected (+18.4) - I’m putting these three here because, although I think the Texans offense is great, I’m taking these numbers with a grain of salt considering they were coming off a bye and facing the worst team in the league. Also, my projections were too low, especially for Dell (3.5 points for a guy who just became one of Stroud's favorite targets with Jaylin Noel on IR), but Stroud has scored under 20 points only once in the past six weeks. He’s quietly having a great season and is currently QB4 in ppr points per game. He threw for 384 passing yards, five touchdowns and an interception in this 44-22 win over the Chargers. That’s a lot of yards and touchdowns to go around and Boutte & Dell were the biggest recipients. Boutte caught 4 of his 5 targets for 125 yards and two touchdowns while Dell caught 4 of 9 targets for 105 yards and a touchdown. While I expect Boutte’s target share to remain relatively low in the future, Tank Dell is obviously one of Stroud’s favorite targets and as long as he’s healthy, he’ll be targeted. Houston can't run the ball, so Stroud has to throw it, and the schedule ahead is soft so if any of these three show up on this list again, they’ll be in the No Duh category.
Darren Waller scoring 23.0 vs 6.1 projected (+16.9) - 8 catches for 90 yards and a touchdown on 10 targets against Denver. That's his best game since week 15 of last season. But he had only six targets in the three games before this, and a lot of this was Denver's zone-heavy defense. Waller is a touchdown-or-bust TE2.
Van Jefferson scoring 16.8 vs 3.2 projected (+13.6) - 5 catches, 58 yards and a touchdown against the Rams. Jefferson had a good game but Stefon Diggs and Antonio Williams are still ahead of him in Washington. Sure his 7 targets was the most on the team this week (tied with Chig Okonkwo actually), but last week he had 1 target. Perhaps that was simply a matter of Washington easing him back from injury and this week’s target share is more indicative of his role going forward, but I’m willing to wait and see.
The Debutant’s Ball
These players are coming out to the world and oh aren’t they beautiful?
Matthew Golden scoring 32.4 vs 13.8 projected (+18.6) - Spoiler Alert: his teammates are in the next category, but I think it’s time we officially give Matthew Golden his flowers. In the Packers’ week 9 drubbing of the Patriots, he caught each of his ten targets for 164 yards and a touchdown. Golden is beating man coverage, getting red-zone looks, and playing in a pass-heavy offense. He’s certainly had some drops this season, but this game announced him as an elite receiver.
"No Duh" We Should Have Seen This Coming
Jordan Love scoring 34.2 vs 16.6 projected (+17.6) and Christian Watson scoring 30.1 vs 14.6 projected (+15.5) - As I mentioned above, the Packers put up 45 on New England. Love threw for 372 yards and two touchdowns and ran in another, a career-high 34.2 points. Watson caught 7 of 8 targets for 171 yards and a touchdown. This is Watson’s third appearance on the overperformers list (weeks 1, 5 and now 9), and he leads the NFL in yards per target. Love is also playing out of his mind after a slow start to the season, he is currently QB3 in total points and QB5 in points per game.
Kenneth Walker III scoring 36.3 vs 21.2 projected (+15.1) - 18 carries for 102 yards and a touchdown, plus 4 catches for 41 yards and two more touchdowns against the Jets. Even projected for 21.2, Walker beat it by 15. He's had a couple down weeks but facing the Jets defense will cure what ails ya. Walker remains one of the best running backs in football and is a No Duh.
CeeDee Lamb scoring 33.5 vs 19.2 projected (+14.3) - 10 catches on 16 targets for 195 yards and a touchdown in Indianapolis. Sixteen targets! Lamb was on the underperformers list in week 5 after leaving with a quad injury, and he's clearly past it. When a team's WR1 gets 16 looks against a struggling Colts defense, this is what happens.
Bucky Irving scoring 28.5 vs 14.8 projected (+13.7) - 20 carries for 97 yards and two touchdowns, plus 4 catches for 28 yards in Chicago. Back in week 5 I called Irving a flash in the pan. In my defense, Baker Mayfield's broken thumb has turned Tampa Bay into a run-first team since then (remember the game where the Bucs didn't complete a pass?). As long as Baker's thumb keeps the passing game grounded, Irving is the offense.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee