All posts
November 5, 20265 min readtristramt

Week 8 Fantasy Underachievers

A look at the players who missed their projections in week 8

week 8 underachievers

The Injury Effect

Typically, a number of the people on the underperforming list will be because of injury. I’m not going to give these players the same attention I give the others because their inclusion on this list doesn’t tell us much other than they have bad luck.

  • Lamar Jackson (−20.5) [Hand/thumb injury on his first snap after missing three games, now on IR and needs surgery, possibly done for the season]
  • Tyler Huntley (−15.0) [Turf toe, left in the 2nd quarter after replacing Lamar]

The Ricochet

These are some players who, while they weren’t injured themselves, saw a dip in numbers because someone else on their team (likely their quarterback) got injured.

Zay Flowers scoring 0.0 vs 19.1 projected (−19.1) - Lamar got hurt on his first snap. Then backup Tyler Huntley left with turf toe in the second quarter. Then Joe Fagnano (third-string) finished the game. The Ravens threw for 68 yards as a team in a 36-10 loss to Buffalo. Flowers was the textbook definition of the Ricochet. The worry is that Lamar may be out for the season, and Flowers had been doing fine with Huntley… and now that the Ravens are trading for Jacoby Brissett, maybe Flowers' season is salvageable.

‘Tis But A Flesh Wound

Michael Penix Jr. scoring -1.9 vs 14.5 projected (−16.4) and Bijan Robinson scoring 7.6 vs 18.1 projected (−10.5) and Drake London scoring 1.8 vs 14.4 projected (−12.6) - Woof. Atlanta got shut out 16-0 in Tampa, and nobody on the Falcons offense did anything. Penix was atrocious, going 8 for 24 for only 125 yards and 4 interceptions. You can blame the rain if you want. Heck Baker Mayfield didn’t complete a single pass… so yeah that’s what we’ll do. We’ll blame the rain. And of course if the quarterback is struggling, so too is his receivers and London sure as heck did with his single catch of 8 yards. We’re just going to ignore Jahan Dotson’s 95 yards, by the way. So if the rain negates the passing game then the Falcons surely leaned on the running game, right? Well, sure… they ran the ball 23 times, but the Buccaneers were able to stifle them with Robinson getting 19 of those carries for only 76 yards. Meanwhile the Buccaneers ran the ball 52 times for 310 yards… The fact of the matter is that this was almost literally a perfect storm for the Falcons going against Tampa Bay’s defense (ranked 2nd in the NFL by EPA per play) in horrible weather. Sure, the Falcons have been disappointing after some great games early in the season, but they won’t be this bad every week.

Parker Washington scoring 3.6 vs 14.3 projected (−10.7) - This is Washington's second time on this list (week 4 was the other) and both times he bounced right back. As I mentioned above Jacksonville’s blowout win over Indy allowed them to lean on Tuten (who showed up in my overachievers post) and all the Jaguars receivers’ targets dried up. In fact, Lawrence only threw 14 times in this game, two of those were to Washington who caught one pass for 16 yards. The concern with Washington is that the Jaguars have a lot of good receiving options and a solid run game so he might not see the monster numbers he saw in week 5 often, but he also shouldn’t see terrible numbers like these often either.

Javonte Williams scoring 6.7 vs 18.5 projected (−11.8) - Well the volume was there, with Williams running 24 times. The opponent was supposed to be soft, with the Cardinals considered one of the worst teams in the league. In fact, according to EPA/Play they are currently ranked as the 19th defense in the league… but the 261 yards they allowed the Cowboys this week ended up being the lowest they’ve allowed all season. But for whatever reason, the Cardinals defense held strong against the Cowboys only allowing Williams 56 yards on those 24 carries. The Cowboys freefall is concerning, but I’m still not worried about Williams.

That Guy Said He Wasn’t Bitten By A Zombie, But He Sure Is Sweaty

Baker Mayfield scoring 1.4 vs 13.4 projected (−12.0) - Baker Mayfield did not complete a pass and yet he still outscored Michael Penix Jr. in both real life and fantasy. Okay, it’s not right to say he outscored Penix in real life, but the Buccaneers sure outscored the Falcons. In fact, in the last two weeks the Buccaneers have outscored their opponents 59 to 13 while Baker has completed merely seven passes. So the question remains: is Baker not passing because he doesn’t need to or because he can’t? Either way, he’s not viable in fantasy until he shows he can actually throw a football.

Matthew Stafford scoring 8.3 vs 19.5 projected (−11.2) - 157 yards, a touchdown and an interception on 25 attempts [against the Chargers. With Davante Adams on IR, the Rams passing game has become the Puka Nacua show, and when Puka isn't going off, there isn't much else. Stafford was on the underperformers list back in week 1 too, and at the halfway point he's one of the bigger disappointments relative to projections. He's not Old Yeller territory, but at 8.3 points he isn't helping anyone.

Old Yeller This Guy (Metaphorically, of course)

Jacoby Brissett scoring 3.5 vs 17.0 projected (−13.5) - Benched late in the third quarter for Gardner Minshew, who then led a comeback win. When your backup comes in and wins the game you were losing, that's not good. But then Brissett got traded to the Ravens, where he will likely start soon so maybe you don’t want to drop him yet.

Tre Tucker scoring 0.0 vs 12.5 projected (−12.5) - Back in week 6 I said Tucker's big games were a lottery ticket. And though he scored over 20 points in week 7, this week Tucker's snap rate dropped to a season-low 54%, and his route participation to 63%. He had one ball thrown his way, which he did not catch. The wide receivers were targeted 5 times in this game, the running back 4 times and tight ends 16 times. Wide Receivers are just an afterthought on this team.

Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.

Buy me a coffee
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.