All posts
October 20, 20265 min readtristramt

Week 5 Fantasy Underachievers

A look at the players who missed their projections in week 5

week 5 underachievers

Here’s a look at some of the players who most missed their projected fantasy points in week 5 of the 2026 season. The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.

The Injury Effect

Typically, a number of the people on the underperforming list will be because of injury. I’m not going to give these players the same attention I give the others because their inclusion on this list doesn’t tell us much other than they have bad luck.

  • CeeDee Lamb (−19.2) [Quad bruise, left in the 4th quarter]
  • David Montgomery (−11.9) [Groin, left early and did not return]
  • Roman Wilson (−9.9) [Dislocated finger, left early and did not return]

The Ricochet

These are some players who, while they weren’t injured themselves, saw a dip in numbers because someone else on their team (likely their quarterback) got injured.

Chris Olave scoring 8.6 vs 17.9 projected (−9.3) - 4 catches on 6 targets for 46 yards against the Vikings. Not a disaster on its own, but when your quarterback throws for 96 yards with a sore hand (see Shough below), there just isn't much to go around. Olave was the best of what was left. When Shough is healthy and not facing Minnesota's blitz, Olave should be fine.

‘Tis But A Flesh Wound

Tee Higgins scoring 4.2 vs 15.8 projected (−11.6) - Higgins had only 4 targets for 2 catches for 22 yards in Cincinnati's game in Miami. If this were against a stalwart defense known for shutting down receivers, I'd understand. Miami is not that defense. Still, Higgins is one of Burrow's go-to targets and one quiet week doesn't change that. I'm not worried.

Carnell Tate scoring 1.6 vs 12.4 projected (−10.8) - The rookie was a little banged up heading into this one and it looked like it. He caught only one of his 5 targets for 6 yards against Houston. I know we were hoping for him to build off his impressive performance from week 4 but, alas, it was not meant to be. The targets are still there though so no worries.

Jeremiyah Love scoring 2.2 vs 12.8 projected (−10.6) - Love has been playing through an ankle injury (not the same one that kept him out all preseason, apparently, which… cool, two ankle injuries) and he was seen getting it worked on during the week 4 loss to the Giants. Love says it isn't bothering him "to the point where I can't play," which is the kind of thing people say when it's definitely bothering them. He had 12 rushes for 22 yards and was targeted once against Detroit. The talent is real and the workload will be there once he's healthy.

T.J. Hockenson scoring 1.7 vs 10.8 projected (−9.1) - One target. One catch. Seven yards. On the other side of that Saints-Vikings game, Hockenson barely got a look. Last week he scored 24.9 points against Miami, so this is more about one quiet game plan than any real change in his role.

That Guy Said He Wasn’t Bitten By A Zombie, But He Sure Is Sweaty

Tyler Shough scoring -0.2 vs 16.7 projected (−16.9) - Negative points. Negative fucking points. I think we’ve gotten to the point where you have to bench your QB if they are facing Minnesota because… my goodness. The Vikings’ blitz heavy defense is a good litmus test for a quarterback because I feel like good quarterbacks who have learned to process the opposing defense quickly can be successful against them but less experienced quarterbacks get exposed. Well Shough got exposed against Minnesota, throwing for only 96 yards and 2 interceptions. He’s on this list and not flesh wound because, despite having a solid first three weeks, his performances have been disappointing lately. Even in those successful three weeks, he really didn’t put up numbers until later in the games. So no, I’m not advocating dropping him yet… Yet.

Chase Brown scoring 7.0 vs 17.8 projected (−10.8) - I usually group teammates together, but while I’m not worried about Tee Higgins’ performance this week, I am concerned about Brown. He’s had a couple good weeks, but he hasn’t lived up to where he was drafted. Against Miami he had 13 rushes for 39 yards as well as 3 catches for 21 yards and a fumble, which isn’t exactly alarming in of itself, but the fact that Samaje Perine had one more rush for 29 more yards might be…

Old Yeller This Guy (Metaphorically, of course)

Case Keenum scoring 0.7 vs 14.0 projected (−13.2) - Back in week 3 Keenum was one of the biggest overperformers of the week. This week? 108 yards and an interception on 19 attempts in Green Bay. [Add how he got into the game: did he relieve Tyson Bagent?] Whatever good vibes he built up in week 3 are gone, and with Caleb Williams on his way back, there's no reason to keep a 38-year-old backup on your roster.

RJ Harvey scoring 0.7 vs 12.3 projected (−11.6) - Even my 12.3-point projection assumed a limited role, and 0.7 points says the role is even smaller than that. Harvey only had 3 attempts for 7 yards and he was targeted once, but it was not caught. Unless something changes in the Denver backfield, he isn't worth the roster spot. Now, given J.K. Dobbins’ history, a change is entirely possible, but still…

Wait, Who Projected That?

In the spirit of honesty: these guys are here because of my projections, not because of anything they did. Listen, my new model is a work in progress.

Tua Tagovailoa scoring -0.6 vs 9.7 projected (−10.3) and J.J. McCarthy scoring 0.2 vs 9.4 projected (−9.2) - Between them: three pass attempts. Tua threw 3 passes for 34 yards and an interception in limited action for Atlanta, and McCarthy didn't throw a single pass for the Giants. Neither one was the starter, so neither should have been projected for nearly 10 points. Backup quarterbacks: still my model's Achilles heel.

Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.

Buy me a coffee
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.