Week 5 Fantasy Overachievers
A look at the players who exceeded their projections in week 5
)

Here’s a look at some of the players who most outscored their projected fantasy points in week 5 of the 2026 season. The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.
The Flash in the Pan
[Note: I have a vivid memory from high school of my PE teacher calling the Foo Fighters a flash in the pan. He was wrong, and I freely admit that I may be wrong here, but these are players that seem unlikely to continue to exceed expectations.]
Bucky Irving scoring 31.5 vs 12.6 projected (+18.9) - Putting up his most points so far this season, Irving’s production could be viewed as more an indictment of the Cowboys’ defense than any positive sign for the Buccaneers' offense. That said, he had 21 rush attempts for 165 yards and a touchdown as well as 2 catches for 10 yards and another touchdown in the Bucs' surprising win over the Cowboys. Hopefully his 31.5 ppr points weren’t wasted on your bench, but given his recent production, it's entirely possible.
Tyler Huntley scoring 24.0 vs 7.2 projected (+16.8) - With Lamar Jackson out, Huntley got the start in Atlanta and threw for 201 yards and two touchdowns with no interceptions, plus 20 rushing yards and another score. That's a great day for a backup. But like Douglas and Williams below, we knew Lamar was out going in, so this doesn't qualify for the Injury Effect. And once Lamar is back, Huntley goes right back to the bench.
DeMario Douglas scoring 22.5 vs 6.3 projected (+16.2) and Kyle Williams scoring 18.1 vs 3.0 projected (+15.2) - These two might qualify for Injury Effect, given Mack Hollins and A.J. Brown being out, but that is usually reserved for when players leave during the game. My projections coming into this game for these two should have reflected the injuries of their teammates (work in progress, remember?). That said, Douglas caught 4 out of 5 targets for 65 yards and 2 touchdowns while Williams caught all three of his targets for 91 yards and a touchdown. Interestingly enough, neither of these two led the team in targets, that honor belongs to Efton Chism the Third. It’s worth noting that Romeo Doubs led the team with 9 targets in week 4… so it really is unclear who the top dog in New England will be going forward.
The Debutant’s Ball
These players are coming out to the world and oh aren’t they beautiful?
Isaiah Likely scoring 32.4 vs 12.3 projected (+20.1) and Malik Nabers scoring 29.1 vs 11.2 projected (+17.9) - Likely has always been good, his problem in Baltimore was just mostly lack of opportunity. I think that’s the main reason he left. And despite playing under the same head coach now in New York, he is getting his opportunity to shine and making the most of it. In the Giants’ tie with the Commanders he caught 11 of his 13 targets for 94 yards and 2 touchdowns. He currently leads the team in targets and now that Jameis has gone back to his gunslinging ways, he’s definitely a top tight end in fantasy going forward. As for Nabers, I originally put him in “No Duh”, because we all know he’s good, but since a great rookie year, there’s been nothing automatic about him. Granted this is because of injuries, both to him and his quarterbacks, but still. But now that Jameis has shaken off the rust, the last two weeks have reminded us how good Nabers actually is. This week he caught 11 of his 20 targets for 121 yards and the game tying touchdown. Yeah, he’s good.
Jaylen Warren scoring 36.8 vs 15.2 projected (+21.5) - I don’t think Warren belongs in the Injury Effect because I think this is who he is. I think he’s an amazing running back and as the Steelers offense continues to evolve and (more importantly) Rodgers' trust in Warren grows, Warren will remain a focal point. In week 5 he rushed for 101 yards and a touchdown while catching all 6 of his targets for an additional 87 yards and another touchdown. 188 yards from scrimmage and two touchdowns is incredible and it made him the second highest scoring running back on the week.
Christian Watson scoring 32.3 vs 13.0 projected (+19.3) - Like Likely, Watson always had the talent, but what he lacked was the opportunity. With a bunch of the other receivers departing in the offseason, the hope was that Watson would finally get those opportunities. Well he has and boy oh boy he’s making the most of them. Like Warren, he was the second highest scorer at his position in week 5 catching 6 of his 8 targets for 143 yards and 2 touchdowns. He’s been this good all season (except for week 4 against Tampa Bay) and this wasn’t even his highest score thus far. So yeah I think Watson has established himself as an elite receiver. Speaking of young receivers becoming elite…
Parker Washington scoring 30.4 vs 12.3 projected (+18.1) - In 2025 the Jaguars spent a boatload to trade up for Travis Hunter as the second pick in the draft. In 2024 they drafted Brian Thomas Jr. #23 overall and he had a stellar rookie season. But it’s their 6th round pick from 2023 that has become their best wide receiver and it's not even a question. He leads the team in targets and that trend continued into week 5 against the Eagles in which he caught 6 of his 9 targets for 124 yards and two touchdowns. Like Watson above, he’s been really good this season (with an exception of week 4) and will likely be showing up in the No Duh section soon.
"No Duh" We Should Have Seen This Coming
Drake Maye scoring 39.5 vs 16.7 projected (+22.8) - Guess who’s back? Back again? Drake Maye’s back. Tell a friend. Yeah he sucked in the first three weeks but has now been QB1 for two weeks in a row. Against the Raiders in week 5 he passed for 374 yards and 4 touchdowns and rushed for 25 more yards and another touchdown. Do you hear that? That’s the sound of a million fantasy owners letting out a sigh of relief.
Puka Nacua scoring 37.7 vs 22.3 projected (+15.4) - Coming into week 5, Puka ranked 86th among all receivers in catches. After that fantastic Monday night game against Buffalo, he is now ranked 6th. He had 17 catches on 24 targets for 128 yards and a touchdown making him the highest scoring wide receiver on the week. What’s there to say about him. He and Adams make a fantastic duo and Stafford will always pepper them.
Jayden Daniels scoring 30.3 vs 15.1 projected (+15.2) - On the other side of that Giants-Commanders tie, Daniels didn't throw a touchdown pass. He didn't need to. He threw for 199 yards, then ran 9 times for 103 yards and two touchdowns. That's the thing about Jayden Daniels: even on a quiet passing day, his legs make him a top fantasy QB. No duh.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee