All posts
October 9, 20265 min readtristramt

Week 4 Fantasy Underachievers

A look at the players who missed their projections in week 4

week 4 underachievers

Here’s a look at some of the players who most missed their projected fantasy points in week 4 of the 2026 season. The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.

The Injury Effect

Typically, a number of the people on the underperforming list will be because of injury. I’m not going to give these players the same attention I give the others because their inclusion on this list doesn’t tell us much other than they have bad luck.

  • Ja'Marr Chase (−12.2) [Concussion, limited in practice]
  • Ladd McConkey (−9.2) [Foot, day to day]

‘Tis But A Flesh Wound

Jaxon Smith-Njigba scoring 12.6 vs 23.5 projected (−10.9) - Listen, a down week was bound to happen. And to be fair, 12.6 ppr points isn’t terrible but it’s bad for him… In fact he scored less than 15 points only twice last season. So maybe this game of 5 catches for 76 yards is just him getting it out of his system. I, for one, am not worried. But if anyone reading this has him in my fantasy league and is worried… we can talk trade.

Parker Washington scoring 2.0 vs 13.5 projected (−11.5) - Listen, none of the Jaguars wide receivers had stellar stats coming out of their win over the Bengals. That distinction belongs to Tight End Brenton Strange who led the team in targets and receiving yards. Still, only 2 targets for the rising star is not what you want to see. He caught one of those targets for seven yards… but this was his first single digit score of the season so we’ll give him a pass.

Dalton Schultz scoring 2.9 vs 13.5 projected (−10.6) - Two targets, two catches, nine yards. Schultz was one of the biggest overperformers in week 2, but this week Nico Collins came back from injury and scored 30.8 points against Dallas, and that's where the targets went. With Collins healthy, Schultz goes back to being a secondary option. A quiet week, but not a worrying one.

Matthew Stafford scoring 9.7 vs 19.8 projected (−10.1) and Davante Adams scoring 7.2 vs 17.2 projected (−10.0) - Stafford threw the ball 51 times in Philadelphia for 317 yards… and zero touchdowns and two interceptions. Fifty-one attempts! Adams caught only 4 of his 9 targets for 32 yards. So where did the points go? Kyren Williams, who scored 36.7 points in the same game. The Rams found success on the ground and the passing game paid for it. Stafford was also on this list in week 1, so keep an eye on him, but I'm not worried about Adams.

Travis Kelce scoring 3.5 vs 13.5 projected (−10.0) - 2 catches on 4 targets for 15 yards in Las Vegas. Meanwhile Tyquan Thornton scored 28.1 points in the same game. Kelce was on the overperformers list back in week 2, and at this stage of his career, weeks like this are going to happen. He's still a starting tight end, just not the guaranteed one he used to be.

Jahmyr Gibbs scoring 17.7 vs 27.1 projected (−9.4) - 15 carries for 46 yards and a touchdown, plus 4 catches for 31 yards. 17.7 points is a perfectly good day for most running backs, but I projected Gibbs for 27.1, and 46 rushing yards on 15 carries isn't up to his usual standard. Carolina held him in check, and Tetairoa McMillan's 45-point explosion on the other side meant Detroit was playing catch-up. Nothing to worry about.

That Guy Said He Wasn’t Bitten By A Zombie, But He Sure Is Sweaty

Dalton Kincaid scoring 1.7 vs 11.0 projected (−9.3) - You shouldn’t Old Yeller Kincaid but man this is beginning to look like more than a flesh wound. This is his second week in a row on the underperforming list and I’m getting a little worried. He says he wasn’t bitten but why does he keep hiding his left wrist? In Buffalo’s loss to the Patriots he caught one of his two targets for 7 yards. In week three he had two catches for 38 yards so he’s actually trending backwards. I’m not advocating dropping him yet, but he might need to be quarantined for a week or two.

Old Yeller This Guy (Metaphorically, of course)

Malik Willis scoring 2.5 vs 11.8 projected (−9.3) - I know no one wants to hear about my fantasy league but I don’t think I was alone this year in thinking I was slick in waiting on QB and grabbing Justin Herbert then waiting even longer on backup and drafting Malik Willis (because of that sweet sweet rushing upside). Well now I look like a fool and my team sucks and that rushing upside? Basically non-existent. In this game he had only 11 rushing yards. His passing yards weren’t much better, 85, and he had zero touchdowns. There’s a lesson here… we knew the Dolphins were going to be at the bottom of the league this year. That was literally their plan. So when someone tells you who they are… believe them.

Kalif Raymond scoring 2.6 vs 11.9 projected (−9.3) - Last week Raymond was one of the biggest overperformers with 21 points. This week? Two targets, two catches, six yards against the Jets. Chicago leaned on Kyle Monangai, who scored 28 points, and Raymond went right back to being an afterthought. Week 3 was the flash, and this is the pan. Let him go.

Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.

Buy me a coffee
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.