Week 4 Fantasy Overachievers
A look at the players who exceeded their projections in week 4
)

Here’s a look at some of the players who most outscored their projected fantasy points in week 4 of the 2026 season. The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.
The Injury Effect
These players outperformed their weekly projections because of an injury to someone else on their team, the opposing defense, or some other one time quirk.
Tyquan Thornton scoring 28.1 vs 6.0 projected (+22.1) - Rashee Rice went down in the first quarter of the Chiefs' game against the Raiders but the Chiefs kept on rolling largely thanks to Tyquan Thornton’s 5 catches for 111 yards and 2 touchdowns. Thornton didn’t do much in his three years with the Patriots nor did he do much with the Chiefs last year but thanks to this performance he has exactly half as many yards in four games this season as he did in 12 last season (219 to 438). I’m not sure the severity of Rice’s injury but Thornton proved himself a viable target for Mahomes.
Kyle Monangai scoring 28.0 vs 9.3 projected (+18.7) - Okay, Monangai’s emergence in this game wasn’t because D’Andre Swift got injured, it was because Swift got benched after fumbling the ball away in the third quarter. But boy did Monangai have himself a game, rushing for 146 yards and 2 touchdowns. After the game, head coach Ben Johnson said Swift would be fine moving forward, but no one believes Monangai’s performance didn’t raise some eyebrows.
Darius Cooper scoring 18.3 vs 2.4 projected (+15.9) - With DeVonta Smith missing this game, someone has to catch passes in Philadelphia. Although rookie Makai Lemon had 6 targets and waiver wire darling Dontayvion Wicks had 7 targets, Cooper had 8 targets. And yes, only three of those were caught but two of those were touchdowns…so… yeah he exceeded his 2.4 projected points this week.
Keon Coleman scoring 23.6 vs 8.0 projected (+15.6) - This is not the first time that DJ Moore has left a game early this season giving Coleman an opportunity to shine. Moore left early in week 2 against the Lions and in that game Coleman had 6 catches for 63 yards. Well this time Coleman also had 6 catches, but he turned them into 116 yards and a touchdown. Coleman’s been an interesting figure in Buffalo the last couple years (I even wrote about it in my deep dive on the 2024 WR class) and he’s been mostly a disappointment. Currently his role seems to be just a handcuff to Moore.
The Flash in the Pan
[Note: I have a vivid memory from high school of my PE teacher calling the Foo Fighters a flash in the pan. He was wrong, and I freely admit that I may be wrong here, but these are players that seem unlikely to continue to exceed expectations.]
Emanuel Wilson scoring 27.0 vs 6.4 projected (+20.6) - Oh the Seattle Seahawks backfield. They let Superbowl MVP Kenneth Walker walk in the offseason and now he’s absolutely killing it in Kansas City. Charbonnet is back from IR after tearing his ACL, but limited in practice and their first round pick Jadarian Price is on IR. That gives Wilson (who recently came over from Green Bay) a chance to shine and boy did he: with 81 rushing yards for a touchdown and 3 catches for 39 yards and another touchdown. I’m putting him in this category because with Charbonnet coming back and them making roster moves, who knows what their backfield will look like week to week.
Brian Robinson Jr. scoring 25.7 vs 6.9 projected (+18.8) - I like Brian Robinson Jr. I think it’s hilarious that there are two B. Robinson running backs on the Atlanta Falcons and that there are people out there who paid up for the wrong one in fantasy drafts. Well, those people kinda got their money’s worth in week 4. Sure, Bijan still outscored Brian by two whole points, but he was drafted second overall to do just that, Brian wasn’t. Brian outscored his projection by nearly nineteen points this week, rushing for 62 yards and three touchdowns against the Saints on Monday night football. Does this make him a surefire starter? No… but you could do worse as a RB2 or Flex.
T.J. Hockenson scoring 24.9 vs 7.9 projected (+17.0) - If your first standout game of the season comes against the Miami Dolphins young defense, then it has to be considered a flash in the pan (Hey listen, I don’t make the rules). Perhaps Hockenson better belongs in the Injury Effect category, since Jefferson missed this game but not like he did much in week 3 when Jefferson went out. But to me this game felt more like Minnesota exploiting a weakness in Miami’s defense: Hockenson caught all 13 of his targets for 119 yards, making him the highest scoring tight end on the week. It’s always nice to see his name on the leaderboard, but given how the Vikings offense looked overall, I’m not sure how often it’ll be there.
Romeo Doubs scoring 23.8 vs 8.2 projected (+15.6) - In his first season in New England, Doubs led the Patriots with 9 targets and caught 6 of them for 58 yards and two touchdowns in Buffalo. That's a big day, but it's 58 yards. Two touchdowns did most of the work. With A.J. Brown, Mack Hollins, DeMario Douglas and Efton Chism all in the mix, the Patriots' target tree is crowded, and Doubs had already been on the underperformers list in week 1. I need to see it again before I believe it.
The Debutant’s Ball
These players are coming out to the world and oh aren’t they beautiful?
Tetairoa McMillan scoring 45.2 vs 12.1 projected (+33.2) - Is Tetairoa McMillan a debutant? Probably not, given his breakout rookie season last year. But in the context of this season, he certainly doesn’t qualify for the “No duh” category. Aside from a stinker week 3 he’s been fine… scoring 10.5 and 15.1 ppr points in the first two weeks respectively, but he wasn’t performing at the level he was drafted at. Well in week 4, he did: nabbing 14 catches for 192 yards and 2 touchdowns. He looked unstoppable out there, and very much the prince who was promised. Now let’s see how he does when Coker comes back.
"No Duh" We Should Have Seen This Coming
CeeDee Lamb scoring 41.3 vs 17.0 projected (+24.3) and Javonte Williams scoring 31.3 vs 13.9 projected (+17.4) - These two guys, man, I tell you what. When Dallas’s offense is humming these two seem unstoppable. Unfortunately, Dallas can’t always get humming (Disclaimer: I am writing this Friday morning, after Dallas’ loss to Tampa Bay on Thursday Night Football). Fortunately for fantasy owners, they were humming against what I was told to be a stalwart Texans defense. Against said defense, Lamb had 17(!) catches for 189 yards and a touchdown while Williams rushed for 62 yards and a hat trick of touchdowns while also catching 5 passes for 21 yards. Yeah these two are pretty good.
Kyren Williams scoring 36.7 vs 15.3 projected (+21.4) - I have never once drafted Kyren Williams in fantasy and every year I regret it. I’m too easily wooed by the young sexy names like Omarion Hampton or Jeremiyah Love… meanwhile Williams is just so damn consistent. Sure, he had two “down weeks” to start the season, scoring 15.5 points in week 1 and 15.7 points in week 2…well each of the other two aforementioned running backs have exceeded 15 points once this season so far… meanwhile Kyren then has a week like this where he ran for 80 yards and 2 touchdowns while also catching 10 passes for 67 yards… reminding me what a weak minded dummy I am.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee