Trade of the Year?
The Minnesota Vikings trading for Kirk Cousins is a big deal (maybe).
)
There were a lot of big trades in what was the busiest NFL trade deadline ever? Of course, the true impact of these trades won’t be obvious for a while, hence the question mark in the title, but there’s a real chance that the Minnesota Vikings trading for Kirk Cousins will go down as the most impactful of this season.
I’ll start this by admitting that I’m not really a fan of the Vikings nor of Kirk Cousins. I have nothing against any of them… in fact one of my favorite stories in the NFL is Andrew Van Ginkle, a defensive end who went over to Minnesota from Miami with Brian Flores and has flourished there. But, like most of the NFC, the Vikings are just another team to me. That said, they’ve been interesting this season because while they have arguably the best defense in the league, their offense is terrible mostly due to the decisions they’ve made at the quarterback position over the past few years culminating in kicking the tires on Kyler Murray. But now they’ve traded for Kirk Cousins from the Las Vegas Raiders. But before I talk about him, let’s look at how the Vikings have done so far this season:

Until two weeks ago, they were the only undefeated team in the league. Since then, they’ve lost two in a row including an offensive performance against Buffalo so bad that the team was forced to finally make a move. But while the offense, led by Carson Wentz, was particularly putrid in that game, it’s not like it had been great prior to it:

As of right now, they are 27th in points per game, 30th in yards per play, 31st in pass yards per game, and dead last in first downs per game. Like I said putrid. So how are they 6-2? Because of their defense:

While they are bottom of the league in most offensive categories, they remain at the top of the league in most defensive categories. Funnily enough, Tampa Bay is below them in many offensive categories and above them in many defensive categories, but that’s a story for a different post. The point is, this defense is superbowl caliber… but the offense is dogshit. Imagine mixing something luxurious and expensive, like some Rémy Martin XO Cognac with liquid dogshit. Would you drink it? No, because it’s still dogshit. But, mix that Congac with something fine, not great like… Coca Cola? Sure… it’s drinkable at least. And that’s where Kirk Cousins comes in. He’s coke.
Kirk Cousins. A fourth round pick in the 2012 NFL draft, and the second QB taken by the Washington Redskins:

To be fair, I left Ryan Lindley, B.J. Coleman and Chandler Harnish off this graphic, a sixth and two seventh round picks, respectively. I hope they’re doing well and wish them all the best but they are irrelevant to this conversation because of all the QBs taken before Cousins, there are some big names and a couple of Superbowl rings. But he is currently the only one still playing. Does that make him the best QB drafted in that class? Depends on your definition of best, I suppose.

That graphic does tell an interesting story though, one of consistency and reliability. He played the second most games, threw for the second most touchdowns and most yards… but has a pretty poor postseason showing for fifteen seasons. But, of course, postseason record is as much a reflection on the team around the quarterback more than the quarterback himself (except with Andrew Luck up there, he just dragged the Colts to the postseason kicking and screaming until his body gave out).
So what does that mean for the Vikings? It means they have a decent starter (who they are familiar with, considering he already played for them) who potentially transforms that offense from dogshit to soda and something they can work with going forward.
But what about fantasy football? Sure, he should be able to right the ship as far as real life goes, but I’m fantasy brained and maybe I drafted Justin Jefferson in the first round. Truthfully, I didn’t, but millions did and they have been regretting it all season. None of the Vikings fantasy players have produced consistently this season (except D/ST). Will that change now?
Probably. Here is a look at the main skill players on all four teams Kirk has played for and their fantasy production with and without him at the helm:

So take this information as you will, I would recommend you take it with a large grain of salt… However, the numbers are pretty clear that players perform better in fantasy with Cousins than without. Of course, that aforementioned grain of salt being that in almost all these cases, the other quarterbacks ranged from bad to terrible… but considering we’ve already established that the QB situation in Minnesota is currently dogshit… fantasy owners of Jefferson and Addison should feel encouraged. Heck anyone who owns a Vikings fantasy player should be encouraged, even D/ST.
So… I am interested to see how the season plays out for the Vikings. In my weekly playoff projection series I had written off the Vikings even when they were still undefeated, but now I can’t write them off anymore. Sure, bad things could happen and they could still tank and miss the playoffs, but their odds of success undeniably rose with this trade.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee