The Good The Bad and The Mid of the First Half (Sort of)
Looking at the players who most overachieved, underachieved and met fantasy projections
)
The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.
The regular season is 18 weeks, and half of 17 games is 8.5 so perhaps I should do this after week nine, but I’m doing a different mid-season award thing next week so this week you’re getting the look at the Good the Bad and the Mid fantasy players as compared to their projections like I did in week 4.
So.. let’s start with the good, shall we?


The top six players that have most outperformed their projections are split right down the middle: three running backs and three wide receivers. Sorry, quarterbacks.
The RBs
It’s worth stating that outperforming projections doesn’t necessarily mean you’re the best at your position. It definitely could mean that (cough cough Jaxon Smith-Njigba, more on him below), but more often than not it means expectations for you were relatively low from the start. Such is the case with all three of these running backs.
Chuba Hubbard (+47.5) is one of only two players on this list who were also on it in week 4, along with JSN. [Hubbard was RBX by ADP coming into the season and is currently RBX in ppr points per game.] Carolina has leaned on him all season and he's scored 133.0 points in 7 games against a projection of 85.5.
Bhayshul Tuten (+47.5) was the RB24 according to ADP coming into the season but is currently the RB12 in ppr points per game. With Tuten there were questions about if he was actually going to replace Etienne or if someone like Chris Rodriguez would. Well, that question has been answered: in week 8 he had 16 carries for 104 yards and a touchdown plus 2 catches for 55 yards and another score, while Rodriguez had six carries. Tuten has had three weeks in which he was slightly under his projection but the rest have been great. And the thing is, we should have seen this coming: we knew the Jaguars have an exciting, innovative playcaller and a young rising quarterback… of course their starting running back is going to find success. Right, Patriots?
Braelon Allen (+41.8) is the outlier of the three, because he's mostly here thanks to someone else's bad luck. Breece Hall has been banged up, and Allen made the most of it with back-to-back big weeks in weeks 7 and 8: 17 carries for 104 yards and 6 catches for 30 yards against Miami, then 23.3 points against Las Vegas. When Hall is healthy, Allen goes back to being a handcuff. But as handcuffs go, he's been about as good as it gets.
The WRs
And then there’s Jaxon Smith-Njigba (+54.7). Back in week 4 he had the fourth largest delta between projections and actual points… Now he has the highest. He also happens to have the most PPR fantasy points in the league. Across all positions (though to be fair, Jahmyr Gibbs has the most points per game, since he’s only played 7 games and JSN hasn’t had a bye week yet). But unlike Gibbs, who you couldn’t get unless you had the very first pick in the draft (Thanks a lot, Ryan Fitzpatrick!), you probably could have drafted JSN. What’s more to say about the guy? He’s game script proof and bad QB proof. He’s the best.
Tee Higgins (+40.7) has the advantage of being the second best receiver on his team and thus his projections reflect that. But Tee Higgins has straight up outscored Ja’Marr Chase this season. Coincidentally, they both have 43 catches on 61 targets, but Chase has 2 more touchdowns than Higgins while Higgins has 234 more yards. Of course, it's worth mentioning that Chase had a slow start to the season while he dealt with a lingering injury, but still, we all knew Higgins was good but he keeps showing us just how good.
Matthew Golden (+40.6) has quietly put together a breakout season in Green Bay: 129.5 points in 8 games against a projection of 88.9.He's beating man coverage, getting red-zone looks, and playing in a pass-heavy offense alongside Christian Watson. He's had some drops, but the Packers clearly trust him.
Now on to the bad…


The bottom 6 players aren’t as evenly divided as the top 6, with four of them being quarterbacks. So let's do them last again. First…
The WRs
I don’t have much to say about Troy Franklin (−30.6) because I really don’t pay attention to the Denver Broncos in regards to fantasy. They are one of the teams on my do not draft list, because Sean Payton is a goddamn menace. I broke this rule in one of my leagues for Jaylen Waddle (because I’m a stupid Dolphins fan), but even Waddle has had a couple decent weeks. Franklin has not. He's scored 13.4 points in 7 games, which is less than two points a game. The thing is, his projections haven’t even been that high, around 6 points a week, and he’s still vastly undershooting them.
Travis Hunter (−29.0) is the most fun player in the NFL and one of the most frustrating in fantasy. 20.4 points in 7 games. The two-way experiment is great for highlight reels: in week 6 he caught a touchdown AND picked off a pass. But he only played four offensive snaps in the second half of that game. You can't start a receiver who doesn't know if he'll be on the field.
The QBs
Sigh… okay let’s do this… Matthew Stafford (−29.0) started the season with 4.1 points in week 1 against the 49ers and has never really recovered. 131.6 points in 8 games isn't terrible on its own, about 16.5 a game, but he was projected for over 20 a week. Davante Adams is on IR and the Rams offense has sputtered more than it should for a team with Puka Nacua.
Then there’s Baker Mayfield (−29.8), who underperformed for 3 games, missed three games, then proceeded to throw the ball 14 times in two games, going 7 for 11 in week 7 and 0 for 3 in week 8. The Bucs won both those games, by the way, by a combined margin of 59 to 13.
Frankly, I just feel bad for Daniel Jones (−33.2). He’s still not 100% recovered from tearing his achilles. He can’t move… and that’s like his whole thing. And the Colts’ response? Trade away their best offensive lineman. I don’t even have the heart to make fun of him.
Last but not least, well yes least, is Justin Herbert (−34.6)… the golden boy, the new Dan Marino. I actually jumped on the bandwagon this offseason. Since I am a stupid Dolphins fan, I was excited to see what Mike McDaniel could do with an arm like that. And… nothing. It turns out he can do nothing with an arm like that. What’s the expression? Necessity is the mother of invention? So with Tua, McDaniel needed to innovate but I guess with someone as talented as Herbert he doesn’t? Herbert’s ADP had him as the QB8. He is currently the QB30 by total points and [QBX] by points per game. Woof. He's also the only player on the bottom six who was there back in week 4, so this isn't a slump. This is who he's been all year.
Finally, the mid.


In week 4 I limited my projection threshold to 30 projected points. A player who was projected to score 0 points and scored 0 points is not interesting. So since 8 is twice the amount of 4, I doubled my minimum projected amount to 60 points. And wouldn’t you know it? Half of the players on this list are quarterbacks. Let’s start with them.
The QBs
Kyler Murray (+0.2) went out early in week 1 and scored −0.4 points, then missed time, and has mostly been… lame since coming back. Fans are calling for him to be replaced, despite his team being 6-1. The Vikings really are the prime example of being carried by their defense, but everyone knows that will only take them so far. At some point, they will have to score, well, points… And yet, somehow, Kyler has scored almost exactly what I projected him for: 71.6 points against a projection of 71.3. Maybe my model just expected him to be lame. Throw in the fact that a new Call of Duty game is coming out soon? Forget about it.
Jameis Winston (0.0) scored 65.3 points against a projection of 65.2 in 6 games. Literally a tenth of a point off. That's the most Jameis thing imaginable: big highs, interceptions, and somehow it all averages out to exactly what you'd expect. Then the Giants benched him for J.J. McCarthy in week 6, so we'll never know what he could have done with the rest of the season.
Jared Goff (−0.5) is the most "mid" player on this list in the truest sense. 142.1 points against a projection of 142.6 over 7 games. He had a big week 2 against Buffalo and some quiet weeks since, but at the halfway point he's exactly the QB we thought he'd be.
The RBs
Christian McCaffrey (+0.5) scored 144.0 points against a projection of 143.5 over 7 games. That's over 20 points a game, which is elite. He's "mid" only in the sense that he's done exactly what everyone expected him to do, which is be great. That's the kind of mid you want.
Woody Marks (−0.4) barely passes my minimum point threshold. He’s simply been a non-factor this season like the rest of Houston’s run game (except Montgomery in week 1, bizarrely). Interestingly enough, he’s 82% rostered on Yahoo because he is getting work and putting up points, just not a ton.
The WR
Nico Collins (+0.2) is mid by averaging out the extremes. He was on the overperformers list in week 4 (+14.5) and the underperformers list in week 7 (−14.8). Put those two weeks together and you get roughly zero. That pretty much sums up his season: 76.1 points against a projection of 75.9 in 5 games. With Tank Dell back and Marvin Harrison Jr. in the mix, the boom-or-bust weeks will probably keep coming.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee