All posts
October 14, 20267 min readtristramt

The Good The Bad and The Mid of the First 4 Games

Looking at the players who most overachieved, underachieved and met fantasy projections

The projections are Rough Draft's own (see the Projections tab) and all the scores are based on PPR scoring.

I know that seventeen games can’t be divided nicely by four, but I’m old enough to remember when the NFL season consisted only of sixteen games: a nice even number. We could talk about the season in quarters and halves and if a team was mid they would go 8-8 instead of this 8-9 or 9-8 bullshit. So I’m still going to look at getting through the first four weeks as a milestone. I know I’m not technically correct (which is the best kind of correct) but whatever…

So, in the spirit of wrapping up the first quarter of the season I’m going to take a look at the six players who have most out performed their projections:

season overachievers

season overachievers week by week

Thoughts:

CeeDee Lamb and Kenneth Walker are the standouts here. The big difference, of course, is that CeeDee Lamb only actually has two weeks in which he beat projections, but boy did he. Kenneth Walker, on the other hand, has been solid every week. Full disclosure, I had originally only looked at the total point differential for each player but I'm glad I drilled down week to week because it really illustrates two types of "good" fantasy players. CeeDee didn't help you in weeks 1 and 3. He didn't necessarily hurt you, but he certainly didn't secure you a W. But he probably got you that W in weeks 2 & 4. Walker, on the other hand helped you in all four weeks. Sure, some weeks were more helpful than others, but he has been nothing but a net positive for you. The same can be said for Kyren Williams who still has yet to be replaced by Blake Corum. The haters are devastated. And then there's Jaxon Smith-Njigba who is just picking up where he left off last season, despite who his quarterback is. Oh, week 4? That little guy? Don't worry about that little guy.

If CeeDee is one type of "good," Tetairoa McMillan is the extreme version of it. He scored 45.2 points against Detroit in week 4, the biggest single-week beat of the season so far. The week before that? 3.7 points against Cleveland. If you started him in week 4, you probably won. If you started him in week 3, you probably regretted it. That's the McMillan experience, and it's why he's on this list: one monster game can carry a whole month.

Chuba Hubbard has always been a blind spot for me. Part of that is his injury history, which includes a hamstring injury this summer that scared many of us away from drafting him. Part of that is the Panthers have been pretty uninteresting when it comes to fantasy (and real life). But given he was the RB33 according to ADP, and currently has the seventh most fantasy points among running backs, he’s turned into one of the biggest steals in the draft. Again.

season underachievers

season underachievers week by week

Thoughts:

Tyrone Tracy Jr. has scored −0.4 points. Total. Over four games. I projected him for about 7.5 a week as the change-of-pace back behind Cam Skattebo, and instead he's been less than nothing. Negative fantasy points over a month of football is genuinely impressive in the worst way. As long as Skattebo is healthy and in good standing, Tracy isn't worth a roster spot.

Saquon Barkley is probably the most disappointing fantasy player in the entire NFL because you likely drafted him in the first round (or spent a lot of money on him in auction drafts). And the thing about this year is that pretty much every first rounder has been good. Some great. But Saquon? The worst. Of course injuries have everything to do with it. Injuries to his offensive line, a terrible blood clot issue with his quarterback and, of course, his own injuries. He's scored 23.0 points in four games against a projection of 52.1, including 3.0 in week 2 and 2.0 in week 4. I’ve heard the quote “You can’t win your league in the first round, but you can lose your league in the first round.” Well if you drafted Saquon, you’re probably losing your league.

Travis Hunter is the most fun player in the NFL and one of the most frustrating in fantasy. 2.1 points in four games. The two-way experiment is great for highlight reels, but you can't start a receiver who doesn't know how much he'll be on the field on offense. Until Jacksonville decides what he is, he's a stash at best.

I don’t have much to say about Courtland Sutton because I really don’t pay attention to the Denver Broncos in regards to fantasy. They are one of the teams on my do not draft list, because Sean Payton is a goddamn menace. I broke this rule in one of my leagues for Jaylen Waddle (because I’m a stupid Dolphins fan). Sutton has 17.6 points in four games, never breaking double digits a single time. The thing is, his projections haven’t even been that high, around 10 points a week, and yet he’s still vastly undershooting them.

Jadarian Price has scored 14.0 points in three games against a projection of 36.8. [Add context: team, role, why the projection was so high — draft capital? expected workload?] Rookie running backs often take a few weeks to earn the trust of their coaching staff, so there's still time… but not a lot.

I’m not going to talk about Kyle Pitts much. I’m so sick of him. Pitts is a player that if you’ve had him before, you’ll never draft him again. We all have that one Pitts season… It's forgivable. It's those of you who are drafting him for the second or third time that I don’t understand. If you are one of those people please let me know what was going on in your head.

closest to projection

closest to projection week by week

Thoughts

A player sticking to their projections can mean a number of things. It can mean they’re consistent, sure… but if they are consistently projected for zero points and always score zero points, that’s not useful information. For the purposes of this infographic I stuck to players with total projections around 30 points or more which comes out to be about 8 points per game, which means they have a significant role in their offense. But even players on this list with high totals doesn’t mean they bullseye their projections each week. They could have had two bad weeks and two great weeks and the sums just happen to even out.

But it brings up a big question in fantasy… Do you want players that simply meet projections? I think ultimately the answer is no. When you look at the highest scoring teams each week, it’s because they have a few players that went off. Using one of my own fantasy teams as an example, in week 5, I exceeded my projections by 3 points. That’s good, right? Well my opponent had Drake Maye, Jahmyr Gibbs, Parker Washington and George Pickens, to name a few. He exceeded his projections by nearly 60 points. Needless to say, I got smoked. So let’s look at the 6 players on this list:

Parker Washington and Malik Nabers are perfect examples of sums evening out. Washington scored 49.1 points in his first three games, then 2.0 in week 4. Nabers scored 1.1 points in week 2 and about 14.5 a game in the other three. One terrible week dragged each of their totals right down to their projections, which makes them look "mid" when they've actually been pretty good most weeks.

Jake Ferguson is the boom or bust candidate on this list, with one week where he outscored his projection by over 10 points and the others at or below it. This is the most frustrating type of player in my opinion. Leave him on your bench after a disappointing week one, then start him after a good week 2 then… meh.

Jeremiyah Love, Aaron Jones and Rashee Rice are the closest thing on this list to genuinely meeting expectations: Love is 0.5 points under, Jones is 0.9 points over, and Rice is 0.7 under in his three games. These are your reliable, unexciting starters. They won't win you a week on their own, but they won't lose you one either.

Anyway, that's all I got on the subject. I plan on doing this again after week 8 so we’ll see if anything changes. Something tells me Tyrone Tracy won’t be on the Under list next time… Travis Hunter, however….

Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.

Buy me a coffee
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.