Playoff Picture After Week 6
It's never too early to talk playoffs
Yes I know it’s only week 6, but this first third of the season is behind us and it's never too early to talk about the playoff picture. Really, it’s just a way to categorize teams and look at who is trending up and trending down. Even after just six weeks, some playoff favorites coming into the season are all but out of it (Chargers, Eagles), while some teams that didn’t seem to have a chance now find themselves in the thick of it (Browns, Panthers).
AFC

AFC East

Nothing too surprising in this division. It’s interesting that Miami had higher chances than the Jets coming into the season but that was quickly corrected. To their credit, the Jets have not been terrible this season, but that’s not really reflected in their record. The Dolphins on the other hand, have been terrible and it is reflected in their record and there is no way they are making the playoffs. The general consensus on the Patriots was that they would have a more challenging road to this post-season than the last one, but it still wouldn’t be that challenging. We were all a bit thrown off by the horrendous showing of their offense in first three games, but they seem to have righted the ship. And they have a tie-breaker over the Bills, which explains the gap closure in week four. The Bills, however, remain the Bills and as long as Josh Allen is playing for them they will be a shoe-in for the post-season (just maybe not that far into it).
AFC North

What a division. They are all bunched together around 50%.In the AFC rankings they take up the 6th through 9th spots and honestly, it's anyone's division at this point. It’s interesting that the Browns are technically number one in the division but have the lowest odds according to this model. That is largely due to their schedule and questions at their roster. But would anyone be shocked if they remained atop the division? They already have 2 division wins under their belt. But, again, they have the shakiest roster. The Bengals offense is stuff of legends even if it hasn’t quite looked like it this season. The Ravens remain the favorite as long as they have Lamar and Henry and the Steelers are… the Steelers.
AFC South

Houston came into the season as the favorites but sure haven’t looked like it, losing four straight. But now with back to back wins, including one over the division favorite Jaguars, perhaps they might have a chance. Their odds were down to 20% after week 4 but have climbed to 36%. Lloyd Christmas certainly wouldn’t be discouraged. But the obstacle that is the Jaguars looms. Week 6 in London aside, it still seems like their division to lose. Also the Colts and Titans are here too.
AFC West

We were all concerned about how Patrick Mahomes would look coming off his ACL tear, and the playoff odds reflected that. But now he looks… well I don’t really know how he looks because all I ever see is Kenneth Walker highlights. But Kenneth Walker looks incredible and so do the Chiefs. The Broncos look… less incredible, but they still win games so… as long as that happens they’ll always have a shot at the postseason (yes, that’s how playoff seeding works… well in the NFL, not college necessarily). The Raiders looked better than expected for the first three games, but that could be a product of who they played because their last three opponents were tougher and it showed. One of those three easy teams they beat, by the way, were the Chargers… who suck! And I don’t say this with glee or anything. I had high hopes for them coming into the season, most of us did. But… wow… they have worse playoff odds than the friggen Dolphins.
NFC

NFC East

Woof. Listen, someone has to win this division and honestly, if I had to put money on it right now? I would pick the Giants. But fortunately I don’t have to do that because… woof. Perhaps the Cowboys are the safest bet just because they’re the only team with a healthy starting QB (yes, I know Jayden Daniels is playing, but he isn’t entirely healthy) but have you seen the Cowboys actually play? Woof.
NFC North

Another interesting division that could easily swing after a week or two. It’s weird that the Vikings are undefeated and sitting atop the division but I still have the least amount of confidence in them. I guess it’s my fantasy football poisoned brain because, sure, their offense is bad (ranked 27th in EPA per play, just above the Miami Dolphins), but their defense is stellar (ranked 1st in EPA per play). Meanwhile the other three teams in the division all have fantasy superstars: Jahmyr Gibbs, Amon-ra St. Brown, Christian Watson and Caleb Williams to name a few… so my brain equates that with success. But each of the teams have flaws and have lost a couple games while the Vikings just haven’t.
NFC South

I liked the Panthers coming into the season. Sure, they stumbled into the playoffs by winning a crappy division despite their losing record. And sure, they lost to the Rams in the first round. But they lost to the Rams by three after beating the Rams by three in the regular season. My point is, the Panthers have moxie: with a young QB who is gaining confidence every week and some impressive talent around him. So I, personally, am not surprised that they find themselves in first place with the only winning record. I keep thinking Atlanta should be better than they are, given the talent they have… but they always seem to disappoint. Tampa Bay just can’t overcome the injuries… again. And New Orleans shows flashes (see that week 2 spike) but also ultimately disappoint as well. Of all eight divisions this is the one where you just expect the worst from all four teams. But, again, hopefully Carolina can keep bucking that trend.
NFC West

There was the briefest moment where we all thought the Cardinals might be better than advertised, but that was before we realized just how shitty the Chargers are this season. Then they lost four straight and even the conversation around their recent win against the Rams has been more about the Rams’ failure and not the Cardinals’ success. Because the failure of those Rams, the so-called super team, is one of the biggest stories of the season. I personally think they’ll right the ship but it might be too little too late given the 49ers success. But the 49ers feel like a time-bomb to me… the injuries have already piled up to the point of concern, especially with Mike Evans going down this week. And then there’s the Seahawks. The reigning superbowl champion isn’t exactly looking the part these days. You can blame the departures of Kubiak or Kenneth Walker or key injuries, particularly to the running game and secondary, but in reality its the combination of all of those and what you end up with is a team depending onSam Darnold to be heroic in third and long and its well documented that that is a recipe for disappointment if not disaster.
Enjoying Rough Draft Football? It's free, ad-free and built by one person.
Buy me a coffee